2023 Banking sector turmoil: It’s not déjà vu all over again
The recent failure of two smaller banks, Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank, has raised concerns about whether we are on the brink of another financial crisis, similar to the 2008 global financial crisis. However, I think that this is not the case, as the 2008 crisis was primarily a credit crisis driven by bad loans and poor credit underwriting, whereas the current crisis is a balance sheet crisis driven by an asset-liability mismatch. However, I believe that the banking sector turmoil will bring changes to commercial real estate market, the technology sector, and private markets.
Not a Re-run of the 2008 Financial Crisis
The failed banks, especially two U.S. smaller banks, Silicon Valley Bank & Signature Bank, focused on a risky and concentrated customer segment, rapidly grew deposits, extended loans when interest rates were low, and assumed interest rates would not quickly rise. This resulted in a risk management failure, triggering the crisis. However, the banking system in 2023 is fundamentally stronger than in 2008. The banking industry now has better capital and liquidity requirements and undergoes stress testing by regulators. Bank holding companies with total assets of more than USD50 billion also have living wills in place, allowing the federal government to take them over and unwind them in an orderly manner, if needed.
If there are further negative repercussions from the recent banking failures, they are unlikely to be systemic in nature, but we think they may change the nature of banking in the US in the medium term. Large banks are likely to get larger, as depositors prefer the safety of larger banks. There may also be an increase in the cost of funding and lower overall profitability, driven by increased competition for funds, potentially higher funding costs if banks diversify funding sources away from large uninsured deposits, and higher costs of capital across banks, especially for small- and mid-cap banks. This would likely imply lower net interest margins and return on equity for the sector, albeit with differences by region, scale, etc. The impact on the US economy is likely to be negative, although the quantum of impact is up for debate.
Commercial Real Estate Being Closely Scrutinized
The failure of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank has raised concerns about the commercial real estate (CRE) market. MSCI estimates that there will be USD 900 billion of commercial real estate loans maturing over 2023 and 2024 that will need to be refinanced in an environment of higher interest rates, lower prices, and weakening demand. Given the importance of smaller and regional US banks in this space, this is a bigger concern for them than for larger banks. There has already been a sharp drop-off in CRE lending activity, which could have a negative impact on the availability of credit to businesses, especially those in the commercial real estate sector.
Tech Ecosystem Change is expected to Come
The banking sector turmoil may also bring change to the tech ecosystem. There could be a negative impact on the availability of funding for startups, which may result in more startups shutting down or selling their businesses. This could also have a knock-on effect on the venture capital firms that have backed them, causing them to take write-downs on their portfolios.
However, on the positive side, it may accelerate a push towards profitability as opposed to the growth-at-all-costs mentality that some tech startups have had in the past.
No Immediate Red Flags on Private Markets
Available information does not suggest immediate red flags in either the private credit or equity markets. However, given their size and growth, regulators are no doubt concerned there may be some hidden risks, and they will be watching the sector closely. Private equity (PE) and private credit (PC) funds are protected in crises by the fact that their end investors commit capital for long periods of time.
However, the risks for PE and PC funds are largely centered around valuations and re-financing risks and costs. If private market transactions occur that would impact how investments are held on their books or with higher cost of refinancing, that may lower prospective returns rather than impairing them. Given the amount of dry powder, it should not detract from the ability to do deals. However, it may change the nature of transactions to focus on deals that require less leverage or that can be primarily financed through equity. In a capital-starved environment, investors could theoretically extract better terms for deals that are completed.
For the PC market, the risk of defaults will have increased given that they typically lend to more leveraged companies. But opportunities will also appear, as banks retreat from extending loans to companies/private equity funds.
In conclusion, while there is a definite sense of "Déjà vu all over again," it is worth reminding ourselves of the differences to prior credit events. Investors should be aware of the increased risks as well as opportunities created by the recent banking turmoil, without needing to be overly bearish or bullish.
-- Contact us at [email protected]
-
Disappointed, Hong Kong migrants return from U.K. Mark O'Neill
Unable to find a satisfactory job and integrate easily into British society, some Hong Kong migrants have returned home – but remain discreet for fear of losing face with their friends and former
-
Visualisation is the best way for communication Dr. Winnie Tang
In recent years, environmental expectations have become increasingly high, and urban development is prone to disputes. The international tournament held at the Fanling Golf Course in March reminded
-
What drives you? Brian YS Wong
“What drives you?” All eyes were on me – the instructor at the front of the class. Before me were thirty eager high-schoolers, ambitious and aspiring, bushy-eyed and cherubic yet by no means naïve.
-
Integration of GIS and BIM can drive development of smart city Dr. Winnie Tang
The China Association for Geospatial Industry and Sciences (“the CAGIS”) released the Top Ten Highlights of China's Geographic Information Industry in 2023, which provides much inspiration. The
-
Equip young people for the future Dr. Winnie Tang
In late February, the inaugural flight of an air taxi from Shenzhen Shekou Cruise Homeport to Zhuhai Jiuzhou Port took only 20 minutes with an estimated one-way ticket price of 200 to 300 yuan per
-
黃家正:從不離棄香港 本地薑音樂節正式回歸
-
CINDY CHAO 20周年系列頌揚生命的律動
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰HUBLOT科技精髓
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰PANERAI賽船情緣
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰TUDOR金光四射
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰ZENITH追本溯源
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰GRAND SEIKO東灜景色
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰JAEGER-LECOULTRE大師之作
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰TAG HEUER尖端破格
-
WATCHES & WONDERS 2024︰ROGER DUBUIS 桀驁登場